Would you leave someone to die?

The greater the number of people present the less likely you are to help.

 A two-year-old girl, Yue Yue, wandering in the street in a market in Foshan, China, was hit by a van. The driver stopped for a moment and continued on, rolling over the girl again with the van’s rear wheels. Over the course of the next seven minutes, as she lay in the street bleeding, 17 passersby walked over and around her—one truck ran over her again—without helping.


Eventually a trash collector stopped to look after the girl and call an ambulance.  Amongst those who ignored her were a cyclist and someone with their own child!

The incident was captured on surveillance cameras and aired on local media.


It is extremely upsetting.


Thousands of pounds were donated to her family to help pay for treatment but Yue Yue died of brain and organ failure. Her injuries were too severe and the treatment had no effect. The parents have said that they will ensure all donations go to helping others (source).

People say the reason is they are too scared, blaming extortion attempts by people who have accused Good Samaritans of causing their injuries; and that they feared it was a scam and they may incur costs. Such as in the case of Peng Yu, who helped an injured elderly lady to hospital was then found by a court to be liable for some of her medical costs.


Another case – in which an elderly woman believed to have fallen in the road accused a man, Xu Yunhe, who stopped to help her, of hitting her with his car – also attracted considerable attention.

China is now considering passing a Good Samaritan Law to help protect people who help strangers from being sued


Previous Classic Social Psychology Examples

The Case of Kitty Genovese

Friday, March 13, 1964, 28-year-old Kitty Genovese was returning home from work. As she approached her apartment entrance (in Kew Gardens section of Queens, New York), she was attacked and stabbed by a man later identified as Winston Moseley .


He stabbed her twice as she hurried past a bookstore on Austin Street, headed to a local bar named Bailey’s to seek assistance. She called out, “Oh my God. He stabbed me. Please help me,” and fell to the ground. Winston was leaning over her to stab her again, when he heard a man’s voice calling from a window in an apartment building across the street, “Leave that girl alone!”

Startled, Mosley ran down an alley, got into his car, and backed up, ready to drive off. Lights had gone on in the nearby apartment building, but they went off again. Mosley got out of the car and again followed Genovese, who had reached the doorway of her apartment building, which was in the back of the building at 82-62 Austin Street. As she fell forward through the doorway, crying out, “I’m dying, I’m dying,” Winston caught up with her, stabbed her again, and then raped her. A short time later, a neighbor, Greta Schwartz, who had called the police after receiving a phone call from another neighbor, ran down to the lobby and cradled Kitty in her lap until the paramedics arrived.

Despite Genovese’s repeated calls for help, none of the dozen or so people in the nearby apartment building who heard her cries called police to report the incident. The attack first began at 3:20 AM, but it was not until 3:50 AM that someone first contacted police.

There were 38 witnesses that claimed they just thought it was a lovers quarrel.


Diffusion of responsibility – less blame. Can think someone else might be better at handling the situation. Someone else will help – so I don’t need to.

Correct and socially acceptable ways – others aren’t responding it must mean a response isn’t required or appropriate.


In a series of classic studies, researchers Bibb Latane and John Darley (1969) in American Scientist, found that the amount of time it takes the participant to take action and seek help varies depending on how many other observers are in the room. In one experiment, subjects were placed in one of three treatment conditions: alone in a room, with two other participants or with two confederates who pretended to be normal participants.

As the participants sat filling out questionnaires, smoke began to fill the room. When participants were alone, 75% reported the smoke to the experimenters. In contrast, just 38% of participants in a room with two other people reported the smoke. In the final group, the two confederates in the experiment noted the smoke and then ignored it, which resulted in only 10% of the participants reporting the smoke.


Darley, J. M. & Latané, B. (1969). Bystander “apathy.” American Scientist, 57, 244-268.
Images used for illustrative purposes only

5 thoughts on “Would you leave someone to die?”

  1. I have no idea why I watched that, as I knew it would have the exact effect it has had. I feel physically sick. Just shows how completely messed up this world is becoming. It’s a really scary place these days and there are often times I actually regret bringing children into it and question if I have made the right decision. I suppose we’re extremely ‘lucky’ with the country we live in as there is so much worse out there. How could ANYONE walk past that? Let alone drive off if you hit her. Disgusting. Those images are going to stay with me for a long time.

    • Sorry I was the same. I said to my husband that if I didn’t know it was “news” I’d think it was just one of those sick prank videos – it was so unbelievably disturbing 🙁

  2. I am sorry but no way I can watch that, I know what it will do to me and no way I am putting myself through that, I would however of stopped to help with out hesitating and faced any possible consequences later, but I am well aware that most others are not the same.

    I was actually going to blog about something very similar a few days ago but I found I went off on a tangent and it ended up being more of a rant fest so I never published it.

  3. I know this is an old post… But i remember seeing the video. I’m definitely a helper not an ignorer.
    I’ve interveined when others walk past before. I clearly remember in kings square an older sibling had pushed a girl down, and was kicking her and calling for help. I swear the rest of the town had gone deaf and blind!!!
    I ran towards the heap of curled up frightened girl “get off that girl” he replies “its fine, she’s ONLY my sister”. I, still running towards shout “you’ve no right to hit ANYONES sister” and he tries to drag her off by her hair and coat.
    I got him off her, shouting and pulling. Offered the girl my hand, gave her a hug. I was well aware someone could accuse me of hurting this girl, but i did not care to be honest. After i’d removed the violent person and yelled for “parent of xxxx come here, or i’m taking her to the police station for her safety”. A few yells of this and people suddenly started to take off their “blinkers”. upsets me to think someone would ignore a child that is being attacked.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.